Venice Tavern Restaurant Review
It
was the least likely night for us to go out for dinner -- Sunday being a
night when Lauren and I would rather just stay home and relax. But alas,
the refrigerator was bare and we decided to venture out. I had visited
Venice Tavern on several occasions during the summer months to enjoy the
wonderful patio that has a marvelous view of the Fox River, while listening
to the musical entertainment and taking in the mellow night air, but I had
not eaten there. The venue used to be a place called Charlie Fox's Pizzeria
& Pub... I had wondered what changes had taken place with the change in
name, so Lauren and I decided to go for dinner. Walking to the front
entryway, the sound of loose bricks under our feet made an interesting and
almost quaint clacking noise as we walked over them, through the small
courtyard and toward the limestone building. Except for the massive amounts
of spider webs attached to every possible part of the facade, front of the
building was quite charming. The door leads directly in to the bar area,
with the dining rooms located toward the rear of the building. The
non-smoking dining area was almost deserted, with a number of diners outside
on the patio, enjoying the last warmth of the season.
The menu was chock full of the
obligatory fried appetizers available in too many restaurants, but also
contained a number of interesting-sounding salads. There was an abundance
of pizza, pasta and sandwich items; the entrees seeming to be almost
entirely Italian in nature. There were however, barbecued ribs and a couple
of steaks on the menu. A buffet was also set up and, according to the
restaurant's website, a lunch buffet is offered Tuesday through Friday as
well. We ordered some cocktails while we tried to decide what we were going
to order.
We did order some Calamari from the
appetizer list... we figured that at $6.50, we couldn't go wrong. It was
delivered hot and crispy; the calamari itself being fairly tender and
tasty. The sauce however was unimaginative and not very spicy; much like
ketchup. For some unknown reason, we both decided to go with the buffet.
We had taken a look and there were a number of salad choices, mostaciolli,
(actually spelled “mostcioli” on the menu -- and it wasn't the only
mistake...), Italian beef, and pizza. There were supposed to have been
meatballs too, but the empty warming dish was never refilled. Perhaps
neither of us wanted to think about what to order and the buffet was easier;
since the available items seemed to be sufficient to satisfy, we went the
way of the buffet... something I normally just will not do.
It was nice to be sitting in a
smoke-free dining room and enjoying a quiet dinner. But as we both looked
around -- at the austere setting and bare table tops, mistake-ridden menus,
cobwebbed ceilings and mundane fare -- neither of us could understand why or
how a place with so much potential could be so mediocre. And that is
exactly what our dinners were that evening: mediocre. Maybe entree choices
off the menu would have been a better idea, but I think the items we tried
gave us a pretty good idea of how things worked in the kitchen.
Although the thin-crust pizza was
decent, the rest was sub-par. Since we chose to go the buffet route, I
can't comment extensively on the service, except to say that our server at
least wore a smile and was nice. She was not however, very knowledgeable
about much. The pictures on Venice Tavern's website show a much different
story from what we experienced. I give the Venice Tavern Two-and-a Half
Zins.

Ralph Pancetta
reviews@ralphpancetta.com
|